|
Statement
of Robert Card
Under Secretary of Energy, Science and Environment
U.S. Department of Energy
Before the
House Committee on Appropriations
Subcommittee on Energy and Water Development
FY
2005 Appropriations Hearing
March 17, 2004
Mr. Chairman and Members of the Committee, I
am pleased to appear before you today to discuss
the President’s FY 2005 budget request
for the Department of Energy, in particular
activities in the area of energy and science.
As Secretary Abraham highlighted
last week, we are requesting $24.3 billion in
gross budget authority. Of the $24.3 billion,
a total $4.2 billion is requested for programs
in renewable energy, nuclear energy, science,
and electricity transmission and distribution,
which I will be discussing with you today. The
FY 2005 budget request for these specific programs
build on a number of successes achieved over
the past three years. I applaud the accomplishments
of the Department in terms of fulfilling the
President’s management vision for DOE
and also what has been achieved for the national,
energy, and economic security of the American
people. I repeat Secretary Abraham’s gratitude
for the support and guidance the Members of
this Committee have provided the Department.
As you now know, the Office of
Management and Budget last month announced that
DOE has made the most progress among cabinet-level
agencies in the implementation of the President’s
Management Agenda. The Department, I am proud
to say, was recognized as the cabinet-level
agency “leading the pack with regard to
management improvement,” in the areas
of human capital, competitive sourcing, financial
management, e-government, and budget/performance
integration.
In addition to the Department’s
successful implementation of the President’s
Management Agenda, I am also proud to mention
the progress we’ve made thus far in our
energy and science portfolio. For example, we
have made tremendous progress in ensuring that
nuclear power remains part of the Nation’s
fuel mix and continue to make great stride in
advanced nuclear research. In addition to nuclear
energy, we are pursuing other new technologies
to meet future energy and environmental challenges.
These are transformative technologies that will
change the way we think about how we use and
produce energy. We are pursuing a path toward
a “hydrogen economy” -- with affordable
zero emission fuel cell vehicles, abundant production
sources, and safe storage and transportation
of hydrogen.
We have also aggressively pursued
international cooperation in order to advance
our initiatives. In a variety of areas, especially
those related to climate change, we have been
able to create partnerships with other countries
to develop the Department’s cutting-edge
science and technology. Our continued pursuit
of fusion energy power through our participation
in the International Thermonuclear Experimental
Reactor (ITER) project could hold great promise
of helping meet our future energy demand. To
ensure the reliability of our energy future,
the Department will also be helping to modernize
and facilitating expansion of our national electricity
transmission grid to help prevent any future
energy disruptions from reoccurring.
With that brief summary, I would now like to
discuss in more detail the following Energy
and Science programs:
THE OFFICE OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND RENEWABLE
ENERGY
OVERVIEW
Research, development and deployment of advanced
clean energy technologies are making a difference
in the daily lives of Americans today and will
make an even larger difference tomorrow. Advanced
energy efficient technologies and practices
that use less energy, as well as renewable energy
technologies that produce power and heat more
cleanly than conventional sources, are well
on their way to becoming today’s answers
to tomorrow’s energy and environmental
challenges.
The overall EERE budget request
for FY 2005 is a robust $1.25 billion, an increase
of $15.3 million over the comparable FY 2004
appropriation. For the renewable energy programs
funded through the Energy and Water Development
appropriation, the FY 2005 request totals $374.8
million, a $17.3 million increase over the FY
2004 appropriation and 30 percent of the total
EERE Budget.
The renewable energy programs
included in the Energy Supply account and funded
solely within the Energy and Water Development
appropriations include Hydrogen Technology,
Solar Energy Technology, Wind and Hydropower
Technologies, and Geothermal Technology. Activities
in the Biomass Program and Intergovernmental
programs are funded through both the Energy
and Water Development and Interior and Related
Agencies appropriations.
HYDROGEN TECHNOLOGY
The FY 2005 budget request for
Hydrogen Technology is $95.3 million, a $13.3
million increase over the FY 2004 appropriation.
Much of the proposed increase is for hydrogen
safety research. This includes safety testing
and analysis on bulk storage systems, fuel dispensing
equipment, and piping to support new codes and
standards specific to hydrogen. The Department
has worked with the Department of Transportation
and other agencies to coordinate our efforts
on hydrogen codes and standards. Under this
activity, we will also develop system safety
requirements for producing hydrogen and sensors
to detect hydrogen leaks.
Research undertaken in the Hydrogen
Technology Program is also targeted to reduce
the cost of distributed hydrogen production
from electrolysis and natural gas reformation.
An enhanced focus on electrolysis, as recommended
by the National Research Council, may lead to
production of hydrogen from renewable energy
at $2.25 per gallon of gasoline equivalent by
2015. Considering the higher efficiency of hydrogen
fuel cells compared with internal combustion
engines that use gasoline, we believe that this
price target will enable hydrogen fuel to be
cost competitive.
Our hydrogen work is well integrated
with the fuel cell and vehicle work funded through
the Interior Appropriations bill. Taken together,
these programs represent the majority of the
Federal efforts comprising the Hydrogen Fuel
Initiative announced by President Bush during
his 2003 State of the Union Address. We have
published very specific, measurable technical
goals against which to measure our progress.
If we achieve our technical objectives, the
automotive and energy industries will be in
a position to consider commercialization by
2015, with mass market availability of both
vehicles and refueling infrastructure by 2020.
SOLAR ENERGY TECHNOLOGY
The Solar Energy Technology program focuses
research on advanced solar devices that can
provide the nation with a widely available domestic
energy resource to help meet electricity needs
and reduce the stress on our critical electricity
infrastructure. Efforts are directed in the
interrelated areas of Photovoltaics, Solar Heating
and Lighting, and Concentrating Solar Power.
The FY 2005 budget request for Solar Technology
is $80.3 million. This is roughly equivalent
to the FY 2004 appropriation of $83.4 million,
which included $3.6 million earmarked to specific
recipients.
Photovoltaic research and development
seeks to reduce the manufacturing cost of highly
reliable photovoltaic modules from $2.10/watt
in 2003 to $1.85/watt by FY 2005, roughly equivalent
to about 20 cents per kilowatt-hour (kWh). This
price will enable expanded deployment of the
technology in niche markets such as remote locations
and areas where peak demand prices are high.
Ultimately, we aim to reduce the cost to about
6 cents/kWh in order to be competitive in most
markets. The program is focused on next-generation
technologies such as thin-film photovoltaic
cells and leap-frog technologies such as polymers
and nanostructures. Systems engineering efforts
seek to increase system durability and develop
technologies to improve interconnections with
the electric grid. The FY 2005 request of $75.4
million for photovoltaics includes: $30 million
for critical fundamental research, including
$2.1 million to equip a new Science and Technology
Facility at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory;
$29 million for advanced materials, including
thin films and next generation materials with
potential for dramatic cost reductions; and
$16.4 million for technology development efforts
to improve reliability of the entire system,
including testing, verification, and deployment
activities for grid-connected applications and
analysis of private sector commercialization
options.
WIND AND HYDROPOWER TECHNOLOGIES
Wind and Hydropower research and development
supports the Nation’s fastest growing
and most widely used renewable energy resources.
These technologies emit no air pollution or
greenhouse gases, and they produce significant
amounts of bulk power to help meet America’s
growing need for clean, domestic sources of
electricity.
Since 2000, installed wind turbine
capacity in the United States has more than
doubled, driven in large part by the tremendous
reductions in cost that have resulted from wind
energy research. Our research contributed to
reducing the cost of electricity generation
by a factor of 20 since 1982, to four cents
or less per kilowatt-hour in areas with excellent
wind resources.
The FY 2005 budget request for
Wind Energy is $41.6 million, $0.3 million more
than the FY 2004 appropriation, which included
$1.4 million in funds that were earmarked to
specific recipients. The $12 million request
for Low Wind Speed Technology research and development
will support multiple large wind system technology
pathways to achieve the goal of three cents
per kilowatt-hour for onshore systems. It also
supports new work in off-shore systems to help
achieve a cost goal of five cents or less per
kilowatt-hour. FY 2005 activities will include
field testing of the first full-scale low wind
speed technology prototype turbine and fabrication
and testing of advanced drivetrains, power converter
and blades for future low wind speed turbines.
The $17 million request for supporting research
and testing will engage the capabilities of
the national labs, universities and private
sector for technical support including both
facility and field tests of newly developed
components and systems to ensure design and
performance compliance.
Hydropower is the most widely
used form of renewable energy in the world today
and accounts for about seven percent of total
electricity generation in the United States
and over 75 percent of domestic renewable electricity
generation. The FY 2005 budget request for Hydropower
Technologies is $6.0 million, a $1.1 million
or 22 percent increase over the FY 2004 appropriation.
The Department’s research approach involves
a unique combination of computer modeling, instrumentation,
lab testing, and field-testing that is improving
the design and operation of the next generation
of hydropower technology. This request will
support development of technologies that will
enable hydropower operators at existing plants
to generate more electricity with less environmental
impact.
GEOTHERMAL TECHNOLOGY
The FY 2005 budget request for Geothermal Technologies
is $25.8 million, a $0.3 million increase from
the FY 2004 appropriation of $25.5 million.
Geothermal energy generates electricity and
provides heat for applications such as aquaculture,
crop drying, and district heating, and for use
in heat pumps to heat and cool buildings. The
program focuses on developing technology that
optimizes the use of geothermal energy through
improved exploration, drilling, reservoir engineering,
and energy conversion. These technology improvements
lead to cost-effective energy production at
new geothermal fields and expanded production
at existing fields.
BIOMASS AND BIOREFINERY SYSTEMS R&D
Biomass and Biorefinery Systems Research and
Development focuses on advanced technologies
to transform the Nation’s domestic biomass
resources into high value chemicals, fuels,
and power. With the U.S. Department of Agriculture,
the DOE biomass program leads the multi-agency
Biomass R&D Initiative that coordinates
all federal bioenergy research and development
in accordance with the Biomass Research and
Development Act of 2000.
In FY 2005, the Department is
requesting $72.6 million for biomass program
activities in the Energy and Water Appropriation,
$13.9 million less than the FY 2004 appropriation.
However, it is important to note that the FY
2004 appropriation required the use of $13 million
in prior year balances, and most available balances
were in the Biomass program. After accounting
for the use of prior year balances, the actual
new budget authority provided to the Biomass
program in FY 2004 was $75.0 million, just slightly
more than our FY 2005 request. Moreover, the
FY 2004 appropriation included nearly $41 million,
nearly half of the biomass budget, targeted
to specific projects not identified in program
plans.
Biomass activities funded through
the Energy and Water appropriation focus on
advanced biorefinery technologies to produce
low cost sugars, syngas and pyrolysis oils.
In FY 2005, the thermochemical program will
test the continuous production, cleanup and
conditioning of biomass syngas and pyrolysis
oils suitable for conversion to fuels, chemicals
or hydrogen, and examine the production of hydrogen
from biomass via synthesis gas. Work will continue
with industry on improved process integration
capabilities for industrial biorefineries, and
the program will evaluate existing partnerships
for more productive and lower-cost cellulase
enzyme systems. Additional partnerships may
further improve the procession operations leading
to cheaper biomass-based sugars. Projects to
test and evaluate the performance and costs
of converting corn fiber to fuels and co-products
will also continue.
NATIONAL CLIMATE CHANGE TECHNOLOGY INITIATIVE
COMPETITIVE SOLICITATION PROGRAM
This is the third year we have sought funding
for the Competitive Solicitation Program as
part of the President’s National Climate
Change Technology Initiative. The competitive
solicitation process will seek to explore innovative,
novel, high-impact climate change technology
options that can complement and enrich, not
duplicate, the existing portfolio of climate
change-related research and applied technology.
By stimulating research in these areas, the
program hopes to broaden and strengthen the
Federal portfolio and inspire private sector
interest and international cooperation in a
collaborative program of research investment
aimed at accelerating technology development
and advancing the Administration’s climate
change goals. The Department is requesting $3
million in FY 2005 for this initiative.
THE OFFICE OF ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION
OVERVIEW
The mission of the newly created Office of Electric
Transmission and Distribution (OETD) is to lead
a national effort to modernize and expand America’s
electricity delivery system to ensure a more
reliable and robust electricity supply, as well
as economic and national security. This is vital
to the Department’s strategic goal to
protect our national and economic security by
promoting a diverse supply and delivery of reliable,
affordable, and environmentally sound energy.
The August 14, 2003 blackout demonstrated
the vulnerability of electric grid and thus
its strategic importance to our Nation. President
George Bush stated in September 2003: “…it’s
clear that the power grid needs an overhaul.
It needs to be modernized. As we go into an
exciting new period of American history, we
want the most modern electricity grid for our
people… we need more investment; we need
research and development…”
We request $90.9 million for OETD
in FY 2005 to increase reliability, a 12.5 percent
increase over the FY 2004 comparable appropriation.
This effort includes research, development,
demonstration, technology transfer, and education
and outreach activities in partnership with
industry, businesses, utilities, States, other
Federal programs and agencies, universities,
national laboratories, and other stakeholders.
Neither government nor industry
alone can satisfy the Nation’s electric
infrastructure needs. The National Delivery
Technologies Roadmap provides a framework for
all of the electric industry stakeholders to
work together to achieve common aims. The call
for grid modernization is coming from all levels
of leadership. The President’s 2004 State
of the Union Address asking Congress to “modernize
our electricity system” reiterated the
Administration’s objectives first outlined
in the National Energy Policy [May 2001] and
reinforced, in more detail, in the National
Transmission Grid Study (NTGS) [May 2002].
Modernizing the grid will involve
time, resources, and unprecedented levels of
cooperation. The nation’s aging electric
infrastructure, and the increasing requirements
placed on it, have contributed to market inefficiencies
and electricity congestion in several regions.
These conditions could lead to more outages,
more power quality disturbances, higher prices,
and the less efficient use of resources. We
must act now or risk even greater problems in
the future.
THE GRIDWISE AND GRIDWORKS INITIATIVES
OETD’s FY 2005 budget request, reflecting
the Administration’s efforts to modernize
and expand the electric grid, includes $10.5
million for the new GridWorks Initiative and
the existing GridWise Initiative, which are
aimed at reducing the likelihood and impact
of reliability events, such as blackouts.
GridWise denotes a modernized
electric infrastructure framework where open,
but secure, communication and information technologies,
and associated standards, are used throughout
the electric grid to enhance reliability and
robustness, promote economic efficiencies, and
provide value and choices to electricity consumers.
The GridWise program activity (software-centric)
comprises the intelligence – or brains
– behind a modern electric grid that incorporates
GridWorks (hardware-centric) technology.
GridWorks is focused on advanced
equipment applications, taking an integrated
approach to the entire electric system. It bridges
the gap between the laboratory prototypes of
the base programs and the application needs
of the electric industry. GridWorks uses the
facilities at DOE’s national laboratories
to accelerate the development and testing of
advanced conductors, which can increase much
needed transmission line capacity. It complements
GridWise’s architectural software development
by developing and demonstrating associated hardware,
such as sensors. GridWorks pursues advanced
power electronic breakthroughs to provide faster
means of limiting transmission problems before
they propagate through the electric system.
HIGH TEMPERATURE SUPERCONDUCTIVITY.
OETD’s FY 2005 budget request includes
$45 million, a $10.9 million increase for High
Temperature Superconductivity R&D to develop
second generation wire usable in cables, generators,
transformers, and motors – equipment that
crosscuts the entire electric power value chain.
High temperature superconductors
are a good example of advanced materials that
have the potential to revolutionize electric
power delivery in America. The prospect of transmitting
large amounts of power through compact underground
corridors, with minimal electrical losses and
voltage drop over long distances, could significantly
enhance the overall energy efficiency and reliability
of the electric system, while reducing fuel
use, air emissions, and any physical footprint.
Also, breakthroughs in basic science are rapidly
applied in the area of high temperature superconductivity.
For instance, benefits from nanoscience research
are accelerating progress in superconductivity
wire development.
THE OFFICE OF NUCLEAR ENERGY, SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
OVERVIEW
The FY 2005 budget request continues the Department’s
commitment to refining the benefits of nuclear
power as a clean, reliable and affordable source
of energy for this nation. The proposed $410
million investment in the Department’s
nuclear energy program includes funding to establish
a new laboratory for nuclear energy research,
development, demonstration and education; preconceptual
design work for the Next Generation Nuclear
Plant; continued work with utilities to pave
the way for an industry order for a new nuclear
power plant in the near future; and continued
work with other countries to develop new reactor
and fuel cycle technologies.
This budget request supports the
President’s priorities to fortify U.S.
energy independence and security while making
significant improvements in environmental quality
through the deployment of non-emitting generation
capacity by the end of the decade. It also strengthens
our nation’s nuclear education infrastructure,
and recommends increased support for the Nuclear
Hydrogen Initiative, which will take high temperature
nuclear energy systems for clean hydrogen production
from concept to reality. Finally, this request
supports funds for the Advanced Fuel Cycle Initiative,
which is aimed at developing proliferation-resistant
fuel cycle technologies to reduce the volume
and toxicity of commercial spent nuclear fuel
and maximize energy from nuclear fuel.
I would like to explain in more
detail how this budget proposal continues to
advance the Department’s nuclear energy
initiatives.
DEVELOPMENT OF THE IDAHO NATIONAL LABORATORY
This budget supports the Secretary’s realignment
of the mission at the current Idaho National
Engineering and Environmental Laboratory to
focus on nuclear energy research and development.
The Department is in the process of establishing
the Idaho National Laboratory, which will combine
the resources of the INEEL and the Argonne-West
site. As the Department’s leading center
of nuclear research and development, a core
mission of this laboratory is advanced nuclear
reactor and fuel cycle technologies, including
the development of space nuclear power and propulsion
technologies. The new Idaho National Laboratory
will play a vital role in the research and development
of enabling technologies for the Next Generation
Nuclear Plant, which will support the Department’s
long-term vision of a zero-emissions future,
free of reliance on imported energy.
The Department’s nuclear
energy program involves the collective talents
of universities, the private sector, international
partners and many of our other national laboratories
– Argonne, Los Alamos, Sandia and Oak
Ridge among them. The rebuilding of the Department’s
nuclear power research and development program,
however, will be centered at INL. While environmental
cleanup remains an important focus at the Idaho
site, real progress is being made that will
aid in the expansion of nuclear research and
development. Within the 2005 budget, an additional
$40.1 million is requested to manage laboratory
infrastructure and security.
GENERATION IV NUCLEAR ENERGY SYSTEMS
The Generation IV program continues to support
the Department’s work to develop advanced
reactor technologies for commercial deployment
in the 2015 to 2030 timeframe. These advanced
reactor concepts offer significant improvements
in sustainability, proliferation resistance,
physical protection, safety and economics. Generation
IV nuclear energy systems will not only be safe,
economic and secure, but also include energy
conversion systems that produce valuable commodities
such as hydrogen, desalinated water and process
heat. These features make Generation IV reactors
ideal for meeting the President’s energy
and environmental objectives.
The development of these reactors
is being led by the Generation IV International
Forum, a group of 10 leading nuclear nations
(Argentina, Brazil, Canada, France, Japan, the
Republic of Korea, the Republic of South Africa,
Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the United
States), plus Euratom. The forum has selected
six promising technologies for next-generation
nuclear energy systems. While the Department
is supporting research on several reactor concepts,
this budget proposal places priority on the
Next Generation Nuclear Plant (NGNP), a Very-High
Temperature Reactor. This emphasis reflects
the NGNP’s potential to economically and
safely produce electricity and hydrogen without
emitting greenhouse gases. FY 2005 NGNP activities
will be focused on the research and development
of fuels and structural materials for high-temperature,
high-radiation environments, and continuing
the preconceptual design activities initiated
in FY 2004. Research and development for the
other Generation IV systems will focus on establishing
technical and economic viability and the resulting
core and fuel designs and materials requirements.
NUCLEAR HYDROGEN INITIATIVES
Hydrogen offers significant promise as a future
energy technology, particularly for the transportation
sector. The use of hydrogen in transportation
will reduce U.S. dependence on foreign sources
of petroleum. Significant progress in hydrogen
combustion engines and fuel cells is making
transportation by hydrogen a reality. The goal
of the Nuclear Hydrogen Initiative is to demonstrate
the economic, commercial-scale production of
hydrogen using nuclear energy. If successful,
this research could lead to a large-scale, emission-free
domestic hydrogen production capability to fuel
a future hydrogen economy.
The Nuclear Hydrogen Initiative
will focus primarily on hydrogen production
technologies that utilize high-temperature nuclear
reactors to produce hydrogen, which then could
supplant fossil fuels in our transportation
system. With funding of $9 million in FY 2005,
the Nuclear Hydrogen Initiative will move toward
demonstrating nuclear-based hydrogen producing
technologies in the laboratory, study potential
hydrogen production schemes, and develop deployment
alternatives to meet growing hydrogen demand.
As previously noted, the Generation
IV program priority is on the Next Generation
Nuclear Plant, which utilizes a Very-High-Temperature
Reactor for advanced hydrogen production and
electricity generation. Investigating and demonstrating
the Generation IV nuclear energy systems will
require advances in materials and systems technology,
including development of high temperature and
corrosion-resistant materials, and advanced
chemical systems analysis. NE is working in
close cooperation with the Department’s
Office of Science, through the Future Energy
Advanced Materials Initiative, to evaluate common
areas of research to develop advanced materials
for use in nuclear hydrogen systems, as well
as Generation IV Nuclear Energy Systems.
ADVANCED FUEL CYCLE INITIATIVE
Of all the challenges affecting the expansion
of nuclear energy in the U.S. and worldwide,
none is more important or more difficult than
dealing effectively with spent nuclear fuel.
After a long and difficult process, the country
is moving forward with licensing a geologic
repository for spent nuclear fuel. This is an
absolute necessity, even as the Department develops
advanced forms of spent nuclear fuel treatment.
The Department plans to submit a license application
for the repository to the Nuclear Regulatory
Commission by the end of 2004.
Research on improving ways to
treat and utilize materials from spent nuclear
fuel will allow the Department to optimize the
first repository, and delay – and perhaps
even eliminate – the need for future repositories.
The Advanced Fuel Cycle Initiative, with an
investment of $46 million for FY 2005, will
continue the progress made in the development
of proliferation-resistant treatment and transmutation
technologies that can reduce both the volume
and toxicity of spent nuclear fuel. These technologies
would support both national security and energy
independence by reducing inventories of commercially-generated
plutonium while recovering residual energy value
from spent nuclear fuel.
The Department is proposing a
research program leading to a demonstration
of proliferation-resistant fuel treatment technology
to reduce the volume of high-level waste, and
the development of advanced fuels that could
allow the consumption of plutonium using existing
light water reactors, or advanced gas reactors.
Under the President’s request, the Department
will continue work toward demonstration of proliferation-resistant
fuel treatment technology and continue design
and testing of transmutation fuels for future
use with current reactor technologies.
For the Advanced Fuel Cycle Initiative
to be successful, advanced fuel treatment and
transmutation research and development must
be integrated with the development of Generation
IV nuclear energy systems, particularly with
those reactor technologies that can produce
very high neutron levels that would be needed
to transmute a wide variety of toxic radioactive
species. To support this goal, the Advanced
Fuel Cycle Initiative will develop the advanced
proliferation resistant fuels and fuel cycle
systems for Generation IV reactors.
NUCLEAR POWER 2010
The President’s Budget supports continuation
of Nuclear Power 2010 in FY 2005 to demonstrate,
in cost-shared cooperation with industry, key
regulatory processes associated with licensing
new nuclear plants in the U.S. The requested
funds of $10 million would support the activities
associated with achieving NRC approval of early
site permits and development of Combined Construction
and Operating License applications.
UNIVERSITY REACTOR INFRASTRUCTURE AND EDUCATION
INITIATIVE
For years, the Energy Department has sponsored
an initiative that supports nuclear science
and technology educational infrastructure through
our University Reactor Infrastructure and Education
Initiative. This program is essential to the
continued operation of the nation’s university
research and training reactors, which play a
vital role in supporting nuclear education and
training.
The growth of nuclear energy in
the United States is dependent on the preservation
of the education and training infrastructure
at universities. Research conducted using these
reactors is critical to many national priorities.
Currently there are 27 operating university
research reactors at 26 campuses in 20 states.
These reactors are providing support for research
in nuclear engineering and other fields dependent
upon nuclear science, including medical isotopes,
human health, life sciences, environmental protection,
advanced materials, lasers, energy conversion
and food irradiation.
Beyond technology and equipment,
DOE’s university program supports the
personnel required for a strong nuclear energy
future. The demand for trained and qualified
nuclear scientists currently exceeds supply.
The FY 2005 budget request includes $21 million
for fellowships, scholarships, nuclear engineering
research, and for critical support to university
research reactors – all of which will
help address the shortage of well-trained nuclear
scientists.
THE OFFICE OF SCIENCE
OVERVIEW
The FY 2005 budget request for the Office of
Science is $3.432 billion, a $68.5 million decrease
from the FY 2004 appropriation levels. When
$140.8 million for FY 2004 Congressionally-directed
projects is set aside, there is an increase
of $72.3 million in FY 2005. When compared to
the FY 2004 comparable President’s Request,
the FY 2005 request increases $104.9 million
or 3.2 percent. This request allows us to increase
support for high priority scientific research,
increase operations at our key scientific user
facilities, keep existing construction projects
on schedule, and support new initiatives. This
request, coming at a time of tight overall Federal
budgets, is also a demonstration of the Administration’s
support for basic research and the role that
fundamental science plays in keeping our Nation
strong and secure.
The Office of Science plays four
key roles in the U.S. research effort. We provide
solutions to our Nation’s energy challenges,
contributing essential scientific foundations
to the energy, national, and economic security
missions of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE).
We are the Nation’s leading supporter
of the physical sciences, investing in research
at over 280 universities, 15 national laboratories,
and many international research institutions.
We deliver the premier tools of science to our
Nation’s science enterprise, building
and operating major research facilities for
open access by the science community. We help
keep the U.S. at the forefront of intellectual
leadership, supporting the core capabilities,
theories, experiments, and simulations to advance
science.
This FY 2005 budget request will
set us on the path toward addressing the challenges
that face our nation in the 21st Century. The
Office of Science has recently released Facilities
for the Future of Science: A Twenty-Year Outlook
which sets an ambitious agenda for scientific
discovery over the next two decades. The priorities
established in this plan—which is not
a budget document—reflect national priorities
set by the President and the Congress, our commitment
to the missions of the Department of Energy,
and the views of the U.S. scientific community.
Pursuing these priorities will be challenging,
but they hold enormous promise for the overall
well-being of all of our citizens. In February
2004 we released an updated Office of Science
Strategic Plan that is fully integrated with
the Facilities Plan, the Department’s
new Strategic Plan, and the President’s
Management Agenda – including the R&D
Investment Criteria and OMB’s Program
Assessment Rating Tool. The FY 2005 budget request
begins to implement these plans.
DOE’s Office of Science
leads the world in the conception, design, construction,
and operation of these large-scale devices.
These machines have enabled U.S. researchers
to make some of the most important scientific
discoveries of the past 70 years, with spin-off
technological advances leading to entirely new
industries. More than 19,000 researchers and
their students from universities, other government
agencies (including the National Science Foundation
and the National Institutes of Health), private
industry, and those from abroad use DOE facilities
each year. These users are both growing in number
and diversity.
We credit our outstanding track
record in construction to a highly effective
management and review process. We have been
so successful that our process is now considered
a “best practice” across the U.S.
government by OMB and OSTP, and we are being
consulted by CERN, Europe’s premier particle
physics laboratory, on construction of their
Large Hadron Collider, a facility to which the
United States (through a partnership between
the Office of Science and the National Science
Foundation) is contributing $531 million.
Because of the extraordinarily
wide range of scientific disciplines required
to support facility users at national laboratories,
and the diversity of mission-driven research
supported by the Office of Science, we have
developed an interdisciplinary capability that
is extremely valuable to some of the most important
scientific initiatives of the 21st Century.
There is also a symbiotic relationship between
research and research tools. Research efforts
advance the capabilities of the facilities and
tools that in turn enable new avenues of research.
The Office of Science funds research
at DOE’s national laboratories and at
280 colleges and universities located across
the country. Excluding funds used to construct
or operate our facilities, approximately half
of our base research funding goes to support
research at universities and institutes. Academic
scientists and their students are funded through
peer-reviewed grants, and SC’s funding
of university research has made it an important
source of support for graduate students and
postdoctoral researchers in the physical sciences
during their early careers.
Office of Science research programs
are managed in seven major areas, including
an enhanced effort in Workforce Development
for Teachers and Scientists.
ADVANCED SCIENTIFIC COMPUTING RESEARCH (ASCR)
ASCR significantly advances scientific simulation
and computation, applying new approaches, algorithms,
and software and hardware combinations to address
the critical science challenges of the future,
and provides access to world-class, scientific
computation and networking facilities to the
Nation’s scientific community to support
advancements in practically every field of science
and industry. The ASCR budget also supports
the Scientific Discovery through Advanced Computing
(SciDAC) program — a set of coordinated
investments across all Office of Science mission
areas with the goal of achieving breakthrough
scientific advances via computer simulation
that were impossible using theoretical or laboratory
studies alone.
The FY 2005 budget includes $204
million for ASCR to advance U.S. leadership
in high performance supercomputing, networking
and software development to continue to advance
the transformation of scientific simulation
and computation into the third pillar of scientific
discovery. The request includes $38 million
for the Next Generation Computer Architecture
(NGA) to acquire additional advanced computing
capability for existing users, and for longer-term
research and development on new architectures
for scientific computers. Enhancements are supported
for ASCR facilities – the Energy Sciences
Network (ESnet) and the National Energy Research
Scientific Computing Center (NERSC). The request
also includes $8.5 million for the new Atomic
to Macroscopic Mathematics research effort to
provide the research support in applied mathematics
needed to break through the current barriers
in our understanding of complex physical processes.
BASIC ENERGY SCIENCES (BES)
The BES program is a principal sponsor of fundamental
research for the Nation in the areas of materials
sciences and engineering, chemistry, geosciences,
and bioscience as it relates to energy. This
research underpins the DOE missions in energy,
environment, and national security; advances
energy-related basic science on a broad front;
and provides unique user facilities for the
scientific community and industry.
For FY 2005, the Department requests
$1.064 billion for BES including $209 million
to continue to advance nanoscale science through
atomic- and molecular-level studies in materials
sciences and engineering, chemistry, geosciences,
and energy biosciences. This supports Project
Engineering Design (PED) and construction on
four Nanoscale Science Research Centers (NSRCs)
and a Major Item of Equipment for the fifth
and final NSRC. NSRCs are user facilities for
the synthesis, processing, fabrication, and
analysis of materials at the nanoscale. The
request also includes $80.5 million for construction
and $33.1 million for operation of the Spallation
Neutron Source and $50 million for design and
long lead procurement of the Linac Coherent
Light Source, a revolutionary x-ray laser light
source. With these tools, we will be able to
understand how the compositions of materials
affect their properties, watch proteins fold,
see chemical reactions, and design matter for
desired outcomes.
The FY 2005 budget request also
includes $29 million for activities that support
the President’s Hydrogen Fuel Initiative.
This research program is based on the BES workshop
report “Basic Research Needs for the Hydrogen
Economy”, which highlights the enormous
gap between our present capabilities and those
required for a competitive hydrogen economy.
BIOLOGICAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (BER)
BER advances energy-related biological and environmental
research in genomics and our understanding of
complete biological systems, such as microbes
that produce hydrogen; in climate change, including
the development of models to predict climate
over decades to centuries; developing science-based
methods for cleaning up environmental contaminants;
in radiation biology, providing regulators with
a stronger scientific basis for developing future
radiation protection standards; and in the medical
sciences, by developing new diagnostic and therapeutic
tools, technology for disease diagnosis and
treatment, non-invasive medical imaging, and
biomedical engineering such as an artificial
retina that will restore sight to the blind.
For FY 2005, the Department requests $502 million
for BER which does not include continued support
for the $141 million in Congressional earmarks
from FY 2004.
Research on microbes through the
Genomics: GTL program, addressing DOE energy
and environmental needs, continues to expand
from $63.4 million in FY 2004 to $67.5 million
in FY 2005. The request also supports initiation
of Project Engineering Design (PED) activities
for the GTL Facility for the Production and
Characterization of Protein and Molecular Tags,
a facility that will help move the excitement
of the Genomics: GTL systems biology research
program to a new level by greatly increasing
the rate and cost-effectiveness with which experiments
can be done. DOE, through the Genomics: GTL
program, will attempt to use genetic techniques
to harness microbes to consume pollution, create
hydrogen, and absorb carbon dioxide.
FUSION ENERGY SCIENCES (FES)
The FES program advances the theoretical and
experimental understanding of plasma and fusion
science, including a close collaboration with
international partners in identifying and exploring
plasma and fusion physics issues through specialized
facilities. This includes: 1) exploring basic
issues in plasma science; 2) developing the
scientific basis and computational tools to
predict the behavior of magnetically confined
plasmas; 3) using the advances in tokomak research
to enable the initiation of the burning plasma
physics phase of the Fusion Energy Sciences
program; 4) exploring innovative confinement
options that offer the potential of more attractive
fusion energy sources in the long term; 5) focusing
on the scientific issues of nonneutral plasma
physics and High Energy Density Physics; 6)
developing the cutting edge technologies that
enable fusion facilities to achieve their scientific
goals; and 7) advancing the science base for
innovative materials to establish the economic
feasibility and environmental quality of fusion
energy.
When the President announced that
the U.S. would join in the International Thermonuclear
Experimental Reactor (ITER) project he noted
that “the results of ITER will advance
the effort to produce clean, safe, renewable,
and commercially available fusion energy by
the middle of this century.” To this end,
the Department continues its commitment to the
future of Fusion Energy Science research with
a FY 2005 request of $264.1 million, slightly
above the FY 2004 level. Within that amount,
DOE’s funding in preparation for ITER
in FY 2005 is $38 million, $30 million more
than last year. Of this $38 million, $7 million
is for engineers who support the International
Team and for the qualification of vendors for
superconducting cable. The other $31 million
is for experiments on our tokamak facilities
and for component R&D in our laboratories
and universities that is closely related to
our ongoing program but which is focused on
ITER’s specific needs. It is important
for me to stress that this means that some U.S.
scientists and engineers will be doing different,
not less, research under the President’s
request.
Fabrication of the National Compact
Stellarator Experiment (NCSX) will continue
with a target of FY 2008 for the initial operation
of this innovative new confinement system that
is the product of advances in physics understanding
and computer modeling. In addition, work will
be initiated on the Fusion Simulation Project
to provide an integrated simulation and modeling
capability for magnetic fusion energy confinement
systems over a 15-year development period. The
Inertial Fusion Energy research program will
be redirected toward high energy density physics
research based on recommendations of the recently
established Interagency Task Force on High Energy
Density Physics.
HIGH ENERGY PHYSICS (HEP)
HEP advances understanding of dark energy and
dark matter, the striking imbalance of matter
and antimatter in the current universe, the
basic constituents of matter, and the possible
existence of other dimensions, collectively
revealing the key secrets of the birth, evolution,
and final destiny of the universe. HEP expands
the energy frontier with particle accelerators
to study fundamental interactions at the highest
possible energies, which may reveal the rest
of the universe: new particles, new forces or
undiscovered dimensions of space and time; explain
how everything came to have mass; and illuminate
the pathway to the underlying simplicity of
the universe.
For FY 2005, the Department requests
$737 million for the HEP program, about the
same as in FY 2004. Highest priority in HEP
is the operations, upgrades and infrastructure
for the two major HEP user facilities at the
Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (Fermilab)
and the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC),
to maximize the scientific data generated.
In FY 2005, the Neutrinos at the
Main Injector (NuMI) facility will be completed
and the beam line will be commissioned. The
FY 2005 budget request also supports engineering
design activities for a new Major Item of Equipment,
the BTeV (“B Physics at the TeVatron”)
experiment at Fermilab to extend current investigations
that use modern detector technology to increase
our data rate by more than two orders of magnitude.
Research, development and design funding continues
in FY 2005 on the proposed Supernova Acceleration
Probe (SNAP) experiment for the DOE/NASA Joint
Dark Energy Mission (JDEM).
NUCLEAR PHYSICS (NP)
NP supports innovative, peer reviewed scientific
research to advance knowledge and provide insights
into the nature of energy and matter, and in
particular, to investigate the fundamental forces
which hold the nucleus together, and determine
the detailed structure and behavior of the atomic
nuclei. Nuclear science plays a vital role in
studies of astrophysical phenomena and conditions
of the early universe. At stake is a fundamental
grasp of how the universe has evolved, an understanding
of the origin of the elements, and the mechanisms
of supernovae core collapse. The program builds
and supports world-leading scientific facilities
and state-of-the-art instruments necessary to
carry out its basic research agenda. Scientific
discoveries at the frontiers of Nuclear Physics
further the nation’s energy-related research
capacity, which in turn provides for the nation’s
security, economic growth and opportunities,
and improved quality of life.
The FY 2005 budget request of
$401 million gives highest priority to exploiting
the unique discovery potentials of the facilities
at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC)
and Continuous Electron Beam Accelerator Facility
(CEBAF) by increasing operating time by 26%
compared with FY 2004. R&D funding is provided
for the proposed Rare Isotope Accelerator (RIA)
and 12 GeV upgrade of CEBAF at Thomas Jefferson
National Accelerator Facility.
Operations of the MIT/Bates facility
will be terminated as planned, following three
months of operations in FY 2005 to complete
its research program. This facility closure
follows the transitioning of operations of the
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory 88-Inch
Cyclotron in FY 2004 from a user facility to
a dedicated facility for the testing of electronic
circuit components for use in space (using funds
from other agencies) and a small in-house research
program. These resources have been redirected
to better utilize and increase science productivity
of the remaining user facilities and provide
for new opportunities in the low-energy subprogram.
WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT FOR TEACHERS AND SCIENTISTS
The mission of the Workforce Development for
Teachers and Scientists program is to continue
the Office of Science’s long-standing
role of training young scientists, engineers,
and technicians in the scientifically and technically
advanced environments of our National Laboratories.
The FY 2005 budget request of
$7.66 million provides $1.5 million for a Laboratory
Science Teacher Professional Development activity.
About 90 participating teachers will gain experience
and enhance their skills at five or more DOE
laboratories in response to the national need
for science teachers who have strong content
knowledge in the classes they teach. A new $0.5
million Faculty Sabbatical Fellowship activity
will provide sabbatical opportunities for 12
faculty from minority serving institutions (MSIs).
This proposed activity is an extension of the
successful Faculty and Student Teams (FaST)
program where teams of faculty members and two
or three undergraduate students, from colleges
and universities with limited prior research
capabilities, work with mentor scientists at
a national laboratory to complete a research
project that is formally documented in a paper
or presentation.
CLOSING
The Department’s FY 2005 request reflects
the accomplishments of the last three years,
the successes and the many changes. It charts
a focused course of investment for the nation’s
future -- one guided by a cohesive mission and
targeted performance metrics. Making all of
this work are the extremely talented men and
women of the Department of Energy which include
the world’s top engineers and scientists.
It is a privilege to work alongside them on
a common mission. It is an honor to serve a
President who has provided this vision of what
this Department can – and will –
accomplish in FY 2005 and beyond.
Thank you. This concludes my formal
statement. I would be pleased to answer any
questions you may have at this time.
|